Poll

Welcher Defragmentierer ist der Nächste? / Which defragmenter is next?

Advanced Defrag
0 (0%)
Ashampoo Magical Defrag 2
0 (0%)
Cobra Apps Cobra File Defrag 1
0 (0%)
PC Mesh: Defrag for Windows 4
0 (0%)
ALikeT Software: Defrag Winner 2
0 (0%)
DiskTrix DefragExpress
0 (0%)
A Software Plus Disk Defrag
0 (0%)
KoshyJohn: DiskMax 4
0 (0%)
Laplink Defrag 11
0 (0%)
mst Defrag Home Edition 3.6
0 (0%)
mst Defrag Prof. Edition 3.6
0 (0%)
Symantec: Norton Utilities
0 (0%)
appsmaker OptimalDisk Basic Free
0 (0%)
appsmaker OptimalDisk Pro
0 (0%)
Markement: PCSuite Defrag
0 (0%)
E-Technik: Power Defrag 3
0 (0%)
Quicksys Disk Defrag beta
0 (0%)
IObit Smart Defrag 2
0 (0%)
Defrag-Defragmenter: Smashing Defrag 3
0 (0%)
UltraDefrag 4
0 (0%)
Vorines Defragmenter
0 (0%)
YL Software: WinUtilities Free Disk Defrag.
0 (0%)
O&O Defrag Pro 15
1 (100%)
Raxco PerfectDisk 12
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Author Topic: Welcher Defragmentierer ist der Nächste? / Which defragmenter is next?  (Read 25209 times)

Chris

  • Administrator
  • Jr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 89
    • www.hofmannc.de
Es gibt viele Defragmentierer, aber ich habe nur wenig Zeit. Also welcher Defragmentierer soll als nächstes getestet werden?

Diese Liste erhebt keinen Anspruch auf Vollständigkeit. Wer noch gute Defragmentierer kennt, kann diese hier posten.

Wichtig: Die bisher getesteten Defragmentierer erscheinen nicht mehr auf der Liste!

/

There are so many defragmenters, but I only have so much time. So what defragmenter shall be tested next?

This list is not exhaustive. Whoever knows about good defragmenters can post them here.

Important: The defragmenter which have been tested so far do no longer appear on the list!
sometimes I believe compiler ignores all my comments

Chris

  • Administrator
  • Jr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 89
    • www.hofmannc.de
Re:Welcher Defragmentierer ist der Nächste? / Which defragmenter is next?
« Reply #1 on: February 06, 2011, 10:30:53 PM »
Die getesteten Defragmentierer Auslogics Disk Defrag, Diskeeper 2010 und Puran Defrag wurden von der Liste entfernt.
Wenn ihr für einen von diesen gestimmt habt, könnt ihr eure Stimme nun einem anderen Defragmentierer geben.

/

The tested defragmenters Auslogics Disk Defrag, Diskeeper 2010 and Puran Defrag were removed from the list.
If you have voted for one of these, you can now vote for another defragmenter.
sometimes I believe compiler ignores all my comments

Chris

  • Administrator
  • Jr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 89
    • www.hofmannc.de
Re:Welcher Defragmentierer ist der Nächste? / Which defragmenter is next?
« Reply #2 on: February 15, 2011, 06:29:24 AM »
Der getestete Defragmentierer Piriform Defraggler wurde von der Liste entfernt.
Wenn ihr für diesen gestimmt habt, könnt ihr eure Stimme nun einem anderen Defragmentierer geben.

/

The tested defragmenter Piriform Defraggler was removed from the list.
If you have voted for this one, you can now vote for another defragmenter.
sometimes I believe compiler ignores all my comments

Chris

  • Administrator
  • Jr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 89
    • www.hofmannc.de
Die getesteten Defragmentierer O&O Defrag Prof. Edition 14 und UltraDefrag 5.0.0b2 wurde von der Liste entfernt.
Wenn ihr für einen von diesen gestimmt habt, könnt ihr eure Stimme nun einem anderen Defragmentierer geben.

/

The tested defragmenters O&O Defrag Prof. Edition 14 andUltraDefrag 5.0.0b2 were removed from the list.
If you have voted for one of these, you can now vote for another defragmenter.
sometimes I believe compiler ignores all my comments

forocomic

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 10
why not iobit smart defrag 2.01 final? It's released 11 April 2011.

Thanks for your web and sorry for my english.

Chris

  • Administrator
  • Jr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 89
    • www.hofmannc.de
Thanks for the hint, I didn't know that the final version has been released already. Of course I will test the final version rather than the beta.
sometimes I believe compiler ignores all my comments

forocomic

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 10
I have 2 defragmenters in my PC now: O&O defrag 14 disabled (service off) and mydefrag. But Mydefrag monthly and daily have a problem for me: is very slowwww. The daily script in my C: (150 GB data of 250 GB total) take 1 hour!!

....and my disk (with mydefrag) feels like my system access to disk more time (I hear my hdd more time than with O&O for example). It is better or worse? (or paranoia XXDDD)

O&O defrag is quicker and it is a very good defragmenter. I don't want use my pc every day (or 2-3 days) for defrag, 1 hour for hdd! (and I have 2). But you said in your conclusion that mydefrag optimize very very good and o&o defrag is ok but worse than mydefrag.

I tried SMART DEFRAG BETA but I see your web and I want to know if SD 2.01 is a good defragmenter or not. (better than O&O and mydefrag).

PD: I have script in mydefrag for monthly but  ... what is monthly (optimize) VS monthly only? I don't have this script. monthly system disk and monthly data disk only in my MYDEFRAG 4.3.1 x64

(sorry fr my english and congratulations for your web (and info))

forocomic

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 10
Ok. I downloaded you optimized scripts

but

OptimizedSystemDiskVariables.MyD?


Thanks

forocomic

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 10
OK. I copy your scripts to my SCRIPTS folder.... I have 3 new scripts in mydefrag.

But:

I have a hdd C: with system win 7
I have a hdd D: with pagefile and data

This 2 hdds are system disk? only c:? and....if D: isn't system disk, where are your optimized scripts for data disks?

and...weekly script is better than daily script for gaming pc?

thanks and sorry for my continuosly questions.

Chris

  • Administrator
  • Jr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 89
    • www.hofmannc.de
I have 2 defragmenters in my PC now: O&O defrag 14 disabled (service off) and mydefrag. But Mydefrag monthly and daily have a problem for me: is very slowwww. The daily script in my C: (150 GB data of 250 GB total) take 1 hour!!
Note that each defragmenter has it's own optimizing strategy. If you run two different defragmenters on one volume they will only shuffle data around without any performance gain. Also note that the MyDefrag Monthly script is very thorough and will move lots of data. I'm going to add another statistic this week that will show the data movement.

OptimizedSystemDiskVariables.MyD?
These are variables for easier customization of the other three scripts (just take a look inside with notepad). You cannot run this script directly in MyDefrag, the other scripts will use it automatically.

This 2 hdds are system disk? only c:? and....if D: isn't system disk, where are your optimized scripts for data disks?
A system disk (from a defragmenters point of view) has the operation system and programs on it. So D: is not a system disk.
There are no optimized Data Disk scripts because there is nothing to optimize. The content and usage of a data disk can be very different, you have to do the optimizing yourself. MyDefrag is called MyDefrag for a reason. ;)

and...weekly script is better than daily script for gaming pc?
The Monthly is even better. ;) Just run this script once and then the weekly about every week.
sometimes I believe compiler ignores all my comments

forocomic

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 10
 
When I installled Mydefrag, O&O is disabled....I don't run 2 defrag at same time! I tried (past) O&O but I am now with Mydefrag with your scripts. I will use DATA DISK for D:

I will run monthly and weekly every week. I will visit your web every day for news and "your conclusion in data disk defrag"

thanks for all.

Chris

  • Administrator
  • Jr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 89
    • www.hofmannc.de
Der getestete Defragmentierer IObit Smart Defrag 2.0 wurde von der Liste entfernt.
Wenn ihr für diesen gestimmt habt, könnt ihr eure Stimme nun einem anderen Defragmentierer geben.

/

The tested defragmenter IObit Smart Defrag 2.0 was removed from the list.
If you have voted for this one, you can now vote for another defragmenter.

sometimes I believe compiler ignores all my comments

forocomic

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 10
thanks for test iobit smart defrag 2.01. I will continue with mydefrag =)

Chris

  • Administrator
  • Jr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 89
    • www.hofmannc.de
You're welcome. :)
sometimes I believe compiler ignores all my comments

Chris

  • Administrator
  • Jr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 89
    • www.hofmannc.de
Die getesteten Defragmentierer DiskTrix Ultimate Defrag 3, Ashampoo Magical Defrag 3 und Paragon Total Defrag 2010 wurden von der Liste entfernt.
Wenn ihr für einen von diesen gestimmt habt, könnt ihr eure Stimme nun einem anderen Defragmentierer geben.

/

The tested defragmenters DiskTrix Ultimate Defrag 3, Ashampoo Magical Defrag 3 and Paragon Total Defrag 2010 were removed from the list.
If you have voted for one of these, you can now vote for another defragmenter.
sometimes I believe compiler ignores all my comments